Booklist: The Last Policeman “is a solidly plotted whodunit with strong characters and excellent dialog.”
The Library Journal: Winters has created “a compelling mystery with surprising twists and turns, but more impressively he has created a world slowly collapsing under the prospect of its imminent demise.
The Concord Monitor “loved the detailed references to Concord; Winters did his homework.” (It’s true. I did.)
The New York Journal of Books: “a well-written mystery that will have readers eagerly awaiting the second installment.”